In my Wharton marketing class on advertising (one of my favorite classes this semester), our major group project for the semester is to create a new advertising strategy for Aquafina: identifying our target audience, what media vehicles to use, allocating budget expenditures, creating a few creative proposals on potential ad executions, etc. We have to produce both a final report and presentation. The top groups in the class get to present in front of Aquafina executives.
Today, the
Aquafina folks came in again to answer some questions for our class which leads to some of my thoughts below:
Differentiation in a Commodity Market
Staying competitive in the water industry is tough, and research shows that there is little brand differentiation (Poland Springs, Deer Park, Dasani, Aquafina, etc..) among consumers of water. However, this does not mean that innovation cannot exist in this established market. Take PepsiCo's
Gatorade or
Glaceau's Vitamin Water for instance. New creative strategies aren't limited to just water.
Remember the Axe effect? These examples illustrate that the key is really to identify a target consumer and build a strong, deep emotional relationship with them.
Date your consumers first. Then marry them. Get them to drink you all the time. The Aquafina lady said (I'm paraphrasing), "Advertising water is like a dating game. You first want to date your consumers. In the current water industry, because of little brand differentiation, it's like showing up to a party where everyone is wearing jeans and a black top. The question is, what happens if you show up with a white top? Will people think you are cool, or will you just come out to be a loser?
How Long Does Your Competitive Advantage Last?
The point the Aquafina lady mentioned made me think more about what it means to be different. Being different can definitely pay off. Some companies even preach it: Apple's Think Different. On the other hand, if you are too different, you might just be going after a non-existing market with not enough consumer demand. On the whole though, I've seen a lot of examples lately where going against the "crowd" is a great strategy in finding precious gems of value. In other words, companies derive their competitive advantage by doing what their competitors aren't doing. My hypothesis is that this competitive advantage may not always be long lasting. When other companies react and respond to what you are doing, the value of that "difference" becomes diminished (e.g. Tag body spray has entered to compete head on with Axe. In fact, their campaigns are so similar that consumers have thought Tag was actually an Axe product, according to David Rubin, Director for Brand Development for Axe North America):
How to avoid losing competitive advantage? Be responsive to market conditions and never cease to innovative. In others words, be observant. Reflect, think, and react...quickly. Whatever happens. Just don't get too comfortable with the way things are.
technorati tags: aquafina, water, commodity, differentiation, competitive advantage, think different